On 14 May 2026 the Supreme Court held 9 to 0 that federal law does not stop a state negligent hiring claim against a freight broker. The ruling set no federal vetting standard, so the work is the same as before and the record of it matters more. Here is a seven step carrier check and a way to run it across your whole list at once.
What does the Montgomery ruling actually say?
On 14 May 2026 the Supreme Court decided Montgomery v. Caribe Transport II, LLC, No. 24-1238. The vote was 9 to 0. Justice Barrett wrote for a unanimous Court that the Federal Aviation Administration Authorization Act (FAAAA) does not block a state claim that a broker negligently hired a motor carrier. The safety exception in 49 U.S.C. 14501(c)(2)(A) keeps that kind of claim alive, so a state court can hear it. The Court reversed the Seventh Circuit and sent the case back.
The facts are worth knowing. The carrier held a conditional safety rating from FMCSA when the broker hired it. Regulators had found it deficient on driver qualification, hours of service, vehicle maintenance and crash rate. One of its drivers ran off the road in Illinois and hit a tractor trailer stopped on the shoulder. The driver in the stopped truck lost his leg. He sued the broker for negligent hiring, and the broker argued that the federal statute shut the case down.
Read the holding closely. The Court decided who may hear the claim. It set no federal vetting standard, created no new duty for brokers and said nothing about whether this broker was careless. Justice Kavanaugh, joined by Justice Alito, wrote separately that the decision should not be read to mean brokers will routinely face liability after crashes. A broker that acted reasonably and arranged transportation with a reputable carrier, he wrote, should be able to defend the suit. That is one Justice's view of how these cases should run. Treat it as context for your file, not as a promise about it.
Which leaves a practical question: can you show you chose with care? That is a records question, and records are something a brokerage can fix this quarter.
Brokers are already pricing it in. In the H1 2026 broker and carrier survey, 49% of brokers named higher freight rates as the biggest expected effect of the ruling, and 18% said they expect to put money into carrier evaluation tools. The broker sample was 141, so read the split as a signal.
None of this is legal advice. We are not lawyers. Talk to your counsel about what your own policy should say.
Montgomery v. Caribe Transport II, LLC, No. 24-1238. Decided 14 May 2026. 9 to 0, reversing the Seventh Circuit. The Court held that the FAAAA safety exception saves a state negligent hiring claim against a broker.
What has changed since the ruling?
The industry is now asking for a federal yardstick. In June 2026, TIA petitioned FMCSA to set a federal Motor Carrier Safety Selection Standard and to publish a list of high-risk motor carriers drawn from FMCSA’s own CSA data. Congress barred FMCSA from publishing those category scores in 2015, so nothing like that list exists today.
Until a standard does exist, the measure is what a careful broker does and can show. That is the checklist below, written down and dated.
What should you check on every carrier?
Run this before the first load, then again on a schedule. Write the date down every time. The list is not a legal standard. It is the work a careful broker can show. The full onboarding packet is a separate job, covered in our guide to the carrier onboarding process.
- Authority is active and the name matches. Pull the MC number and read the legal name, the docket and the status. If the name on the rate confirmation is not the name on the authority, stop until someone clears it.
- Insurance is filed and the limit fits. A for-hire carrier files proof of public liability cover with FMCSA before its authority activates, on form BMC-91 or BMC-91X. The federal floor for general freight is $750,000. Many brokers and shippers ask for $1,000,000 or more, so compare the filing with your own contract requirement.
- The safety rating is not a surprise. FMCSA assigns one of three ratings after a compliance review: satisfactory, conditional or unsatisfactory. Driver qualification, hours of service, maintenance and crash rate all feed it. A conditional or unsatisfactory rating is a conversation to have before you tender. The carrier in Montgomery was conditional when it was hired. Most carriers have no rating at all: in FMCSA’s data, about 94% of interstate freight carriers were unrated in 2021, because a rating needs an on-site review. Unrated is normal, so look at inspection history, out-of-service results and crashes instead.
- Identity matches the record. Check the email domain, the phone number and the address against the public record. Ask for the name of an officer and call the number on file, not the one in the email signature. A database cannot do this part for you.
- Payment changes get a phone call. If a carrier asks to change where it gets paid, dial the number you already had on file and speak to a person you have dealt with before. Never confirm banking details by reply email.
- You keep the record. Date, what you checked, what you found, who checked it. One line per carrier is enough to start, and it beats a clean memory.
- You set the next check date. Authority and insurance move after onboarding. Pick an interval in your written policy and keep to it. Any interval beats a one-time check.
Why is a lookup not enough on its own?
A lookup tells you what the public record says. It does not tell you who is on the phone.
Fraudsters work under a legitimate carrier's MC number. The authority is real and active, so the record reads clean while someone else books your load. In the TIA fraud survey, 20% of respondents named identity theft as the most frequent fraud they saw, and 22% named email spoofing.
Annie Singh at Shine Logistics Group described a carrier her team had vetted at 95 out of 100, with insurance verified. The people behind it had taken a real company's identity, altered details across several verification portals and put a leased truck under another name. The load, close to $291,000 of artificial nails, vanished. Her words: "We did everything right, yet they still scammed us." That is why the checklist above includes phone checks that no database can do.
Double brokering tends to surface after pickup, when tracking goes dark or a second carrier asks to be paid. Our guide to double brokering covers the red flags at the dock.
Scale explains why checks get skipped. TIA's survey put unlawful brokering as the most frequent fraud type for 34% of respondents, and 65% of companies said they spend more than two hours a day on prevention. That survey drew 59 responses, so read it as a signal rather than a census.
The money is real. TIA's president told a congressional subcommittee that brokerage fraud costs brokers, carriers, shippers and consumers $800 million or more a year. On the cargo side, Verisk CargoNet put the average value per theft at $273,990 in 2025, up from $202,364 the year before, across 2,646 confirmed cargo theft incidents.
Where does a bulk check fit?
The carriers you onboarded last year are the blind spot. Their authority, insurance and rating may have changed since, and nobody emailed you about it.
Checking a hundred carriers one at a time is an afternoon nobody has. So the check gets skipped, and the skip is invisible until a claim lands.
A bulk check turns the list into one table. Our free bulk carrier audit takes up to 150 MC or USDOT numbers per paste, one per line, separated by commas, or dropped in as a CSV. It reads each number against public FMCSA records and returns authority status, insurance on file, authority age and flags, sorted so the carriers that need a look sit at the top. Download the findings as a CSV or print the record, and each flagged carrier carries a re-check date.
It cannot catch a stolen identity. Nothing that reads public records can, which is why the phone checks above still matter. What it does is settle the record checks across your whole carrier list at once, so your team spends its calls on the carriers that need a human. For one carrier, use the free MC and DOT carrier check.
What do you do with the flags?
Sort the table by how serious each flag is, then work it like a queue.
- Serious. Stop booking until someone has called the carrier and cleared the issue. Write down what you found and who cleared it.
- Worth a look. Ask for a current certificate of insurance or an explanation, and set a short re-check date.
- No record. Treat it as a stop until you confirm the number is right. A typo in a paste looks the same as a bad carrier.
- Clean. Keep the dated record and move on. A clean result today says nothing about next quarter, so the re-check date still matters.
Keep the CSV with the load file. It shows what you checked, when, and what you did about it, which is the whole point of the exercise.
How do you keep this inside your TMS?
A spreadsheet works for a one-off audit. It lives apart from your loads, and the person who needs it in a hurry is rarely the person who built it.
UltraShip is a TMS for non-asset freight brokers. In carrier onboarding, you enter an MC or DOT number and Gateway pulls the carrier record, applies your risk rules the same way to every carrier and flags new authority, contact mismatches and identity red flags at intake. The packet, W-9, COI and carrier agreement file on the profile, the decision carries a date, and you can re-check any carrier against live FMCSA data at any time.
When you source capacity in CarrierQ, every result shows its vetting state, and a carrier who is not onboarded yet flows into onboarding before anything books. The carrier you vet is the one you book and pay, on the same record as the load and the invoice.
If you want to see that on your own carriers, book a demo. Bring a real list.
Common questions
Do brokers have to vet every carrier after Montgomery?
The ruling leaves that question to state law and to your contracts. The Court held only that a state negligent hiring claim against a broker is not preempted. It set no federal vetting standard and no list of required checks. Ask your counsel what your written policy should require, then follow it every time.
How often should I re-check carriers?
Set the interval in your written policy, then keep to it. Authority can be revoked and insurance can lapse between loads, so a check from last year proves little about today. Re-check sooner when the freight is high value or the carrier is new. Write the date on the record every time you look.
Does a clean result mean a carrier is safe?
No. It means the public record looked clean on the date you checked. A stolen MC number passes a record check because the authority behind it is real and active. Pair the lookup with identity and payment checks: call the number on file, compare the email domain and confirm any payment change by phone.
How many carriers can I check at once?
Up to 150 MC or USDOT numbers per run in the free bulk carrier audit. Paste them one per line, or separated by commas or spaces, or drop a CSV or text file and the tool pulls out every number it finds. Duplicates are merged and anything over 150 is trimmed with a message.
Is the bulk carrier audit free?
Yes. There is no account and no signup, and UltraShip does not store your list: the numbers go to FMCSA's open data service and come back as one table you can download as a CSV or print. If it is useful, a demo is how you see the same checks inside the TMS.
What did the Supreme Court decide in Montgomery v. Caribe Transport?
On 14 May 2026 the Court held 9 to 0 that the federal FAAAA does not block a state negligent hiring claim against a freight broker, because the law’s safety exception keeps that kind of claim alive. It reversed the Seventh Circuit. The ruling set no federal vetting standard.
What should a broker do if a carrier has no safety rating?
Treat it as normal, not as a pass or a fail. About 94% of interstate freight carriers were unrated in FMCSA’s 2021 data, because a rating needs an on-site review. Look at the carrier’s inspection history, out-of-service results and crash record, confirm authority and insurance, and write down what you found.
Paste up to 150 MC or USDOT numbers and get one page of authority, insurance and flag findings, each carrier with a re-check date. Audit my carrier list →
Bring a real carrier list and see Gateway vet it inside the TMS. Book a demo →
- The Court held 9 to 0 on 14 May 2026 that the FAAAA safety exception saves a state negligent hiring claim against a broker; Justice Barrett wrote for the Court and Justice Kavanaugh concurred. Montgomery v. Caribe Transport II, LLC, slip opinion, No. 24-1238
- Case facts: the carrier held a conditional safety rating when hired, the Illinois crash, the leg amputation, the unanimous vote, and Kavanaugh's concurrence that a broker acting reasonably with a reputable carrier should be able to defend the suit. SCOTUSblog, Court rules freight brokers can face negligent hiring suits under state law
- 49% of brokers named higher freight rates as the biggest expected effect of the ruling and 18% expect investment in carrier evaluation tools; broker sample of 141. H1 2026 freight broker and carrier survey, press release
- Proof of public liability insurance is filed with FMCSA on form BMC-91 or BMC-91X before authority activates; the federal minimum for general freight is $750,000; a cancellation starts a 30 day clock to revocation. O Trucking, motor carrier insurance requirements
- FMCSA assigns one of three safety ratings, satisfactory, conditional or unsatisfactory, after a compliance review. 49 CFR Appendix B to Part 385, safety rating process
- 20% of respondents named identity theft and 22% email spoofing as the most frequent fraud; 34% named unlawful brokering; 65% spend more than two hours a day on prevention; 59 responses; the Shine Logistics case and Annie Singh quote. TIA, State of Fraud in the Industry, April 2025
- Brokerage fraud costs brokers, carriers, shippers and consumers $800 million or more a year, per TIA president Anne Reinke's congressional testimony. Trucking Dive, brokerage fraud costs could surpass $800M
- Average value per theft of $273,990 in 2025, up from $202,364, across 2,646 confirmed cargo theft incidents. Verisk CargoNet, 2025 cargo theft analysis
- About 94% of 690,091 interstate freight carriers had no FMCSA safety rating in 2021 FreightWaves: feds told to start rating unrated trucking companies
- TIA’s June 2026 petition for a federal Motor Carrier Safety Selection Standard and a public high-risk carrier list; Congress barred publication of CSA category scores in 2015 Overdrive: brokers want FMCSA to publish list of high-risk carriers
